# Former Pakistani prime minister Benazir Bhutto was assassinated in 2007 amid a documented official cover-up, and the masterminds who ordered her killing have never been established

**No verdict.** Two layers have to be kept apart. The killing and the cover-up around it are documented: Benazir Bhutto was assassinated at a Rawalpindi rally on 27 December 2007, and a 2010 United Nations Commission of Inquiry found that her security was “fatally insufficient and ineffective” and that the police investigation was so mishandled it amounted to a whitewash, most notoriously the hosing-down of the crime scene within roughly two hours. Who ordered the attack is a separate, unresolved question. The Musharraf government blamed Pakistani Taliban leader Baitullah Mehsud and al-Qaeda; a 2017 anti-terrorism court convicted two police officers of negligence, acquitted five alleged militants for lack of evidence, and declared former president Pervez Musharraf a fugitive without trying the charge. The UN commission reached no conclusion on the organizers and sponsors. This file reports the cover-up as documented and attributes every claim to the commission and the courts rather than accusing any individual in the site’s own voice.

Category: Government & Intelligence · Era: 2000s · First circulated: Within hours of the 27 December 2007 attack, when the Musharraf government blamed Baitullah Mehsud and rival theories immediately pointed at elements of the state; the UN inquiry reported in 2010 and the anti-terrorism court ruled in 2017 · Believed by: That Bhutto was assassinated and that the investigation was botched is the mainstream account, backed by a UN commission and a Pakistani court. Who ordered the killing remains genuinely open: theories range from the Pakistani Taliban and al-Qaeda to elements within the state, and none has been established in law.
URL: https://theconspiratory.com/theory/benazir-bhutto-assassination

## Summary
On 27 December 2007, former Pakistani prime minister Benazir Bhutto was killed as she left an election rally at Liaquat Bagh in Rawalpindi, standing through the escape hatch of her vehicle when a gunman fired and a suicide bomb detonated, killing more than twenty other people. Her death, weeks before a general election and after years in exile, convulsed Pakistan. This file separates two things that are often blurred. The first is the documented core: the assassination itself and the official failures around it, which a 2010 United Nations Commission of Inquiry described as fatally insufficient security and a prejudiced, whitewashed investigation, including a crime scene hosed clean within hours. The second is the contested question of who planned and ordered the attack, which the UN commission expressly declined to answer and which no court has resolved. The cover-up is established; the masterminds are not.

## The claim
That Benazir Bhutto was deliberately assassinated at a Rawalpindi rally in December 2007; that the security around her was so inadequate, and the subsequent investigation so deliberately compromised (the crime scene washed down, an autopsy blocked, evidence lost), that officials must have been covering something up; and that the identity of whoever planned and ordered the killing has never been honestly established, whether Islamist militants, elements of the Pakistani state, or some combination of the two.

## Origin and timeline
- 2007-10-18: Bhutto returns to Pakistan from years of self-imposed exile to contest the coming election. A suicide bombing targets her homecoming procession in Karachi that night, killing some 140 people; she survives. She publicly warns that she faces threats and complains that her security is inadequate.
- 2007-12-27: Leaving a rally at Liaquat Bagh in Rawalpindi, Bhutto stands through the escape hatch of her armored Land Cruiser to wave to supporters. A gunman fires and a suicide bomb detonates beside the vehicle. Bhutto dies; more than twenty others are killed. A 15-year-old attacker is later identified as the bomber.
- 2007-12-28: The Musharraf government announces it has intercepted a phone call attributing the attack to Baitullah Mehsud, head of the Pakistani Taliban (TTP). Mehsud’s spokesman denies any involvement. The Interior Ministry also points to al-Qaeda and the militant group Lashkar-e-Jhangvi.
- 2007-12-27: Within roughly two hours of the blast, police hose down the attack site, washing away forensic evidence before it can be collected. A post-mortem examination of Bhutto’s body is not carried out. Both actions become central to later findings of a botched, compromised investigation.
- 2008-02: A Scotland Yard team invited to assist concludes Bhutto most likely died from a head injury sustained when the blast threw her against the vehicle’s escape-hatch lever, not from a gunshot. Her party rejects the finding and insists she was shot. The dispute over the cause of death remains bitter.
- 2010-04-15: The United Nations Commission of Inquiry, led by Chilean diplomat Heraldo Muñoz, delivers its report. It finds that Bhutto’s security was “fatally insufficient and ineffective,” that her death could have been prevented, and that the investigation was prejudiced and hampered by intelligence agencies. It reaches no conclusion on who organized or sponsored the attack.
- 2013-08: A Pakistani anti-terrorism court indicts former president Pervez Musharraf, who ruled at the time of the killing, on charges of murder, criminal conspiracy, and facilitation of murder in connection with the assassination. Musharraf denies wrongdoing; his health problems and later departure abroad stall the proceedings.
- 2017-08-31: After nearly a decade, the anti-terrorism court delivers its verdict. It convicts two police officers, Saud Aziz and Khurram Shahzad, of negligence and mishandling the case, sentencing each to 17 years, while acquitting five alleged TTP militants for lack of evidence. It declares Musharraf an absconder and orders his property seized, without trying the murder charge against him.
- 2023-02-05: Pervez Musharraf dies in Dubai, having lived in self-imposed exile since 2016 and never having stood trial on the Bhutto charges. Appeals in the case continue in the Pakistani courts, and the question of who ordered the assassination remains formally unresolved.

## The evidence, claim by claim
- Claim: Bhutto was deliberately assassinated in a planned attack, not killed in random violence.
  Evidence: This is settled. She was targeted as she left an election rally by a coordinated gun-and-bomb attack, the second attempt on her life in just over two months after the Karachi bombing of her homecoming. The UN commission, the Pakistani courts, and every serious account treat it as a planned political assassination.
- Claim: The security provided to Bhutto was grossly inadequate, given the known threats against her.
  Evidence: The UN Commission of Inquiry found exactly this, in unusually blunt terms. It concluded that the security arrangements by the federal government, the Punjab provincial government, and the Rawalpindi police were “fatally insufficient and ineffective,” that none of those bodies responded adequately to the fresh and specific threats she faced, and that her death could have been prevented. This is a formal finding of an international inquiry, not speculation.
- Claim: The crime scene was deliberately washed away and the investigation was covered up.
  Evidence: The physical fact is documented: police hosed down the attack site within roughly two hours, before evidence was collected, and no post-mortem was performed on Bhutto. The UN commission found the investigation was prejudiced and severely hampered by intelligence agencies and officials, amounting in effect to a whitewash. In 2017 a court convicted two senior police officers over the mishandling. Whether this served to protect the actual masterminds, or was bureaucratic self-protection, the commission did not resolve.
- Claim: The government proved that the Pakistani Taliban and al-Qaeda ordered the killing.
  Evidence: It did not. The Musharraf government asserted, the day after the attack, that an intercepted call tied the killing to TTP leader Baitullah Mehsud, and the Interior Ministry blamed al-Qaeda and Lashkar-e-Jhangvi. Mehsud denied involvement. When the case finally reached judgment in 2017, the court acquitted all five alleged militant suspects for lack of evidence. The militant-network theory is plausible and widely held, but it was never established in court, and the destruction of the crime scene helped ensure it never could be.
- Claim: A court found former president Musharraf responsible for the assassination.
  Evidence: No. Musharraf was indicted in 2013 on murder and conspiracy charges, and in 2017 the court declared him a fugitive and ordered his property seized after he failed to appear. But being declared an absconder is a procedural consequence of not showing up, not a conviction: the murder charge against him was never tried, and he died in 2023 without a verdict. The legal record establishes that he was charged and fled the proceedings; it does not establish that he ordered the killing, and this file does not assert that he did.
- Claim: Because the perpetrators were never convicted, the whole case is unknowable.
  Evidence: That goes too far the other way. A great deal is firmly established: that Bhutto was assassinated, that her protection failed catastrophically, and that the investigation was compromised, all of it documented by a UN commission and, in part, by a criminal court. What remains unproven is the specific chain of command that planned and ordered the attack. “We do not know who ordered it” is accurate; “nothing is known” is not.
- Claim: The cause of death itself was manipulated to obscure what happened.
  Evidence: The cause of death is genuinely disputed but not clearly manipulated. The Scotland Yard team concluded Bhutto died from a head injury caused by the blast throwing her against the escape hatch; her party maintains she was shot. Because no autopsy was performed and the scene was washed down, the forensic basis to settle the question was destroyed. The dispute is real, and it is itself a product of the botched handling rather than proof of a specific deeper plot.

## Why people believe it
- The official failures are extraordinary and documented. A former prime minister was killed after her own government provided security a UN commission called “fatally insufficient,” and police then hosed the crime scene clean within hours. When the state’s conduct looks that much like a cover-up, suspicion that it was covering for someone is a natural, not a fringe, reaction.
- The government’s explanation arrived suspiciously fast. Blaming Baitullah Mehsud the very next morning, on the strength of an intercept the public could not examine, struck many as a story reached for before any real investigation, which made people distrust the whole militant narrative.
- Bhutto had powerful enemies on more than one side. She had returned to challenge a military-backed order, had survived an attempt weeks earlier, and had reportedly named people she feared. With plausible motives running from Islamist militants to entrenched elements of the state, almost any theory can point to a real-world grievance.
- No one has ever been convicted of the murder itself. Nearly two decades on, the only convictions are of police officers for mishandling the case, while the alleged militants were acquitted and the one indicted political figure died untried. An unsolved killing of this magnitude invites theories to fill the vacuum.

## Open questions
- Who planned, financed, and ordered the assassination has never been established. The UN commission expressly reached no conclusion on the organizers and sponsors, the 2017 court acquitted the alleged militants, and the destruction of the crime scene removed much of the evidence that might have answered the question.
- Why the crime scene was hosed down within hours, and the autopsy blocked, remains only partly explained. A court found the responsible officers negligent, but whether the mishandling was incompetence, routine self-protection, or a deliberate effort to shield the perpetrators has never been resolved.
- The true cause of death is still contested. The Scotland Yard finding of a fatal head injury from the blast conflicts with her party’s insistence that she was shot, and because no post-mortem was performed, there is no forensic record capable of settling it.
- How the militant and state-linked theories relate, if at all, is unresolved. The possibility that local militants carried out an attack that others enabled or tolerated is widely raised, but the compromised investigation means the interaction between the operational cell and any higher direction was never traced.

## Sources
- UN report on Bhutto murder finds Pakistani officials ‘failed profoundly’, UN News (United Nations) (2010): https://news.un.org/en/story/2010/04/335482
- U.N. report: Benazir Bhutto’s assassination was preventable, CNN (2010): https://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/asiapcf/04/15/pakistan.bhutto.report/index.html
- UN Blames Pakistan For Failing To Protect Benazir Bhutto, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (2010): https://www.rferl.org/a/UN_Report_Pakistan_Failed_To_Protect_Bhutto/2015067.html
- Report of the United Nations Commission of Inquiry into the assassination of Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto, United Nations Security Council (2010): https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/125434/5067_UN_Bhutto_Report_15April2010.pdf
- 5 Cleared, 2 Convicted In Bhutto Murder Case, But 1 Major Suspect Still At Large, NPR (2017): https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/08/31/547531794/5-cleared-2-convicted-in-bhutto-murder-case-but-1-major-suspect-still-at-large
- Pervez Musharraf: Former Pakistan leader declared fugitive in Bhutto murder case, CNN (2017): https://www.cnn.com/2017/08/31/asia/pakistan-benazir-bhutto/index.html
- Missing Evidence from Bhutto’s Murder, TIME (2008): https://time.com/archive/6942208/missing-evidence-from-bhuttos-murder/
- Who killed Benazir Bhutto?, Dawn (2017): https://www.dawn.com/news/1378568
- Assassination of Benazir Bhutto, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Benazir_Bhutto

Rated by The Conspiratory, a neutral, sourced encyclopedia of conspiracy theories. Full page: https://theconspiratory.com/theory/benazir-bhutto-assassination