# The Circleville Letters were written by someone other than the man convicted for the case

**No verdict.** Paul Freshour was convicted in 1983 of the attempted murder tied to the campaign, yet the anonymous letters kept arriving while he was imprisoned and, at times, in solitary confinement. No one has ever been definitively identified as the writer, and the record neither cleanly confirms nor cleanly clears him.

Category: Unsolved Crimes & Disappearances · Era: 1970s–1990s · First circulated: 1977 · Believed by: A lasting true-crime fascination, sustained by a 1994 Unsolved Mysteries segment, decades of retrospectives, and Freshour's own public protestations of innocence until his death
URL: https://theconspiratory.com/theory/circleville-letters

## Summary
Beginning in 1977, residents of Circleville, Ohio received a flood of anonymous, threatening letters that exposed intimate personal secrets. The saga ran through the 1977 death of school bus driver Ron Gillispie, a 1983 roadside booby-trap, and the conviction of Paul Freshour for attempted murder, and yet the letters continued to arrive while Freshour sat in prison. The writer's identity has never been established.

## The claim
That the person convicted in connection with the Circleville letter campaign, Paul Freshour, was not the anonymous writer (or at least not the only one) because the letters kept coming while he was incarcerated and unable to send them, and that the true author of thousands of poison-pen letters was never identified.

## Origin and timeline
- March 1977: Residents and businesses in Circleville, Ohio begin receiving anonymous letters postmarked from Columbus. School bus driver Mary Gillispie is a primary target, accused of an affair with the married school superintendent, Gordon Massie.
- August 1977: Mary's husband, Ron Gillispie, receives a phone call and, according to his family, leaves the house with a gun to confront the writer. He dies when his pickup leaves the road and strikes a tree; his gun has been fired once and his blood-alcohol level is elevated, though relatives insist he rarely drank. The coroner rules the death an accident.
- 7 February 1983: Mary Gillispie stops her bus to tear down an obscene sign about her daughter posted on her route. It is rigged to a cardboard box concealing a small-caliber pistol wired to fire when the sign is pulled. The trap fails to go off.
- March–October 1983: The pistol's filed-down serial number is raised by Ohio's Bureau of Criminal Investigation and traced to Paul Freshour, Mary's former brother-in-law, recently separated from Ron Gillispie's sister. A grand jury indicts him for attempted murder.
- October 1983: After document examiners testify that the anonymous letters could be in Freshour's handwriting, a jury convicts him on 28 October; on 31 October he is sentenced to an indefinite term of seven to twenty-five years.
- 1983–1994: The letters keep arriving in Circleville throughout Freshour's imprisonment, including a stretch when a warden placed him in solitary confinement. Freshour himself reportedly receives a taunting letter in prison.
- 1994: Freshour is paroled after roughly a decade behind bars. The letters cease. That November, an Unsolved Mysteries segment on the case airs; the production reportedly receives a postcard from the purported writer warning it away from Sheriff Dwight Radcliff. Freshour maintains his innocence until his death in 2012.

## The evidence, claim by claim
- Claim: The letters continued to arrive in Circleville while Paul Freshour was imprisoned, even during periods when he was held in solitary confinement without writing materials, so he could not have been the writer.
  Evidence: This is the case's central and best-documented anomaly. Multiple accounts, including Freshour's own, report that anonymous letters kept circulating through his incarceration, and that a frustrated warden placed him in isolation to no effect. The point can be read two ways: as proof he was never the writer, or as evidence of an accomplice who continued the campaign. Neither has been proven, which is precisely why the case stays open.
- Claim: The pistol hidden in the roadside booby-trap was traced to Freshour, tying him physically to the attempt on Mary Gillispie's life.
  Evidence: Investigators did raise the filed-off serial number and match the gun to Freshour, and it was the linchpin of the prosecution. But Freshour said the pistol had been stolen from his home, no physical evidence placed him at the sign, and he offered an alibi for part of the window when the trap was set. A gun that once belonged to a suspect is not the same as a suspect caught building a trap.
- Claim: Document examiners testified that the anonymous letters matched Freshour's handwriting, identifying him as the author.
  Evidence: Two examiners testified the letters could be his, and that testimony helped convict him. Critics note the comparison sample was obtained by having Freshour copy an existing Circleville letter rather than supply independent writing (a method that invites the very match it seeks), and that attributing deliberately disguised block printing to one person is notoriously unreliable. The handwriting link is suggestive, not conclusive.
- Claim: Ron Gillispie was lured to his death by the writer in 1977, making the campaign a murder rather than mere harassment.
  Evidence: The circumstances are genuinely strange: a reported threatening phone call, a gun fired once, a high blood-alcohol reading for a man said not to drink. But the coroner ruled the single-vehicle crash an accident, and no forensic finding ever established foul play. The death remains an accident of record that many close to the case simply do not believe.

## Why people believe it
- The core fact resists every tidy explanation: letters kept arriving while the convicted man was locked up and, at times, in solitary. When the official story requires the impossible, people reasonably conclude the official story is wrong.
- The writer seemed to know everyone's secrets (affairs, rumors, private details) that in a small town reads less like a single crank and more like an omniscient insider, feeding the sense that the truth was hidden in plain sight.
- The forensic case was thin. A traced gun the defendant said was stolen, a contested handwriting test, no eyewitness, a partial alibi. A conviction built on inference is one many observers find easy to doubt.
- Officialdom left loose ends dangling: an accidental-death ruling few accepted, a booby-trap that reads like something out of fiction, and a purported postcard warning a TV crew away from the county sheriff. Ambiguity from authorities is the soil conspiracy grows in.
- National television sealed it. The 1994 Unsolved Mysteries segment turned a local terror into a durable American mystery, and each retelling since has kept the unanswered question alive.

## Open questions
- How did the letters continue to arrive in Circleville throughout Freshour's years in prison (including while he was reportedly in solitary confinement) if he was the sole writer? Either he was not the writer, or someone else carried the campaign on, and neither possibility was ever resolved in court.
- Who actually built and placed the 1983 booby-trap? The gun was traced to Freshour, but he claimed it was stolen, no physical evidence put him at the scene, and he had an alibi for part of the relevant window. The mechanics of who assembled and hung the device were never independently established.
- Was Ron Gillispie's 1977 death truly an accident? A reported threatening call, a gun fired once, and an elevated blood-alcohol level in a man said not to drink all sit uneasily beside the coroner's accident ruling, and none of it was ever reconciled.
- Who sent the postcard the Unsolved Mysteries production reportedly received while filming, warning it away from Sheriff Dwight Radcliff? If genuine, it suggests the writer was still active in 1994 and attentive to the case's public life.

## Sources
- Poison Pen Murder, Unsolved Mysteries (official archive): https://unsolved.com/gallery/poison-pen-murder/
- The Circleville letters: Anonymous letters threaten to expose an Ohio town's rumored secrets, CBS News: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/circleville-letters-ohio-rumors-secrets/
- Has the anonymous author of the infamous Circleville letters been unmasked?, CBS News: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/circleville-letters-author-unmask/
- State v. Paul L. Freshour, 97-CA-20 (Ohio Ct. App., Dec. 1, 1997): appellate record of the conviction and post-conviction history, Ohio Court of Appeals (via vLex) (1997): https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/state-v-paul-l-885265069
- Inside the Eerie Mystery of the Circleville Letters That Terrorized an Ohio Town for Nearly 20 Years, All That's Interesting: https://allthatsinteresting.com/circleville-letters
- Unknown Sender: The Mystery of the Circleville Letters, Mental Floss: https://www.mentalfloss.com/crime/circleville-letters-unsolved
- Circleville Writer, Unsolved Mysteries Wiki (Fandom): https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Circleville_Writer

Rated by The Conspiratory, a neutral, sourced encyclopedia of conspiracy theories. Full page: https://theconspiratory.com/theory/circleville-letters